By Craig Underwood
Net:
Forecast Senate Outcomes:
High Confidence: 55 D/ 44 R / 1 I
Democrats win Georgia (hold), North Carolina, New Hampshire (hold), Maine, Michigan (hold), Ohio, Kansas, and Texas.
Dream Scenario: 58/ 41/ 1
Add South Carolina, Mississippi, and Iowa
CLICK HERE TO ACCESS OUR INTERACTIVE POLL SENSITIVITY SENATE RACE MAP
The Details:
Happy Election Day, everyone! I am writing from York, Maine, where I have spent the last four days knocking on doors as a member of the Maine Democrats Get Out The Vote (GOTV) team. I have also spent my evenings phone banking in Tennessee for my friend and former Year Up colleague Justin Pearson, who is running for Congress in Tennessee’s 9th district. Please see the graphic and map above, and my “net” summary of this article, for my latest and final predictions for today’s election. My forecasts are based on the following:
- Almost all macroeconomic indicators point to a high level of success for Democratic candidates: prices/inflation, specifically the cost of gas/diesel/groceries, interest and mortgage rates, etc. And Democratic candidates, for the most part, have done a great job sticking to the “it’s the economy, stupid” message, although I think they could have done a much better job explaining how they will get prices down. Here’s what I tell people in Maine and Tennessee that Democrats will do immediately: 1). Repeal the tariffs. 2). End the war in Iran. 3.) Increase the minimum wage. 4). Reverse the cuts in ACA/ Healthcare and SNAP subsidies and benefits. 5). Ensure that the wealthy pay their fair share of taxes.
- Our analysis of the polls, including sensitivity if the polls overstate the Democratic vote as has happened in several previous elections. If you look at in the matrix chart at the end of this article, you will see the following: Column F shows the latest polls (NYT/ Sienna Poll from November 1). In our analysis of 76 Senate Races from 2014-2024, any candidate – Republican or Democrat – that was ahead by at least 4 points in the last credible (i.e., not partisan-leaning) poll wins the race. Column A shades the states in green where the Democratic candidate leads by at least 4 points in the NYT/Sienna poll. Note that those in bold italic font show seats that would represent a “flip” from Republican to Democratic party affiliation: Kansas, Maine, North Carolina, and Texas. Column G shows the change in polling from the latest average of credible polls to the last NYT/ Sienne poll. In 12 of the 17 states we are watching, the latest polls show movement in favor of Democrats, indicating undecideds are breaking for Democratic candidates and that many of these candidates have strong momentum heading into Election Day.
- Early vote analysis indicates higher voter turnout for Democrats than in past mid-term elections.
- From my work in both Maine and Tennessee, it appears that the Democrats have a clear GOTV organization advantage. One of the things I do when canvassing for a campaign is to try and sign up for GOTV work for the other team. In Tennessee, I found no evidence of an organized GOTV effort for the Republicans, and in Maine, I tried to sign up to work for Susan Collins, but no one got back to me! Compare this to Justin Pearson’s campaign in Tennessee, where he has 6 full-time field organizers on his team and hundreds of volunteers making phone calls and knocking on doors.
- I see no evidence of overconfidence for Democrats. Although the latest polls show Troy Jackson ahead by 6%, everyone I have talked with in Maine over the past 4 days has said they believe the race is “very close,” and everyone has either voted or has a plan to vote. I also like the term “Red Undertow” that someone coined to mean that many traditional Republican voters will either not vote this year, or just leave the Senate race blank while voting for other Republican candidates. One of my good friends and CEO-Coaching clients recently told me that he has “Never voted for a Democrat in my life, but I just voted for Talarico.” I don’t think he is alone.

That said, I remain paranoid and am likely suffering from prior election and GOTV PTSD. I worked in Maine for Sara Gideon in 2000. She was ahead by 3% in the polls, and Biden won the state, but Susan Collins beat her by almost 5%. I also worked for Kamala Harris in 2024 in Allentown, PA (which she won), and we know how that election turned out. So, it’s time for me to stop writing and resume knocking on doors and driving voters to the polls!





